Pulpit AI vs Pastors.ai: A Small-Church Buying Checklist
Pulpit AI and Pastors.ai solve the same Monday problem. The sermon has been preached, and a church without a media team wants clips, a study guide and a devotional without spending the week making them.
They get there in different ways. Pulpit AI is an upload-based workspace with unlimited clips, a caption style editor, a sermon-prep assistant and a Subsplash connection. Pastors.ai is built around a YouTube link, inbox delivery, one-click posting and a chatbot you can put on your church website.
We make Amenflow, a third tool in this category, so we are not neutral and will say so. We have no affiliation with either company. Pulpit AI details come from pulpitai.com and pulpitai.com/pricing. Pastors.ai details come from the homepage and pricing section at pastors.ai. All were checked November 9, 2026. Both companies change their pages, so confirm prices and limits there before you buy.
Side by side
| Pulpit AI | Pastors.ai | |
|---|---|---|
| Starting point | Upload video, audio, PDFs, docs or slides. Media already in the Subsplash Dashboard can be used without re-uploading | Paste a YouTube sermon link, or let it fetch sermons from your YouTube channel. Manuscript upload (PDF, DOCX, PPT, RTF, TXT) is also offered |
| How the work arrives | In the Pulpit AI app, where you review key points, quotes, Scripture and the transcript | Emailed to you, with the homepage saying about 30 minutes |
| Clips, as listed | Unlimited custom and automatic clips on every plan | Free: 3 per sermon with a watermark. Pastor: 8. Team: 15 |
| Caption control | Fonts, colors, size and karaoke-style highlighting | Captions, music, speaker centering and your church logo added automatically |
| Written pieces they advertise | Summaries and transcripts, group guides, discussion questions, daily devotionals, blog posts, newsletters and recap emails, related passages, illustrations and application | Study guide and discussion questions, 5-day devotional, branded sermon page, quote graphics (with manuscripts) |
| Chat | Unlimited chat with your sermon, plus a sermon assistant for prep | Sermon chatbot trained on your sermons and church site, which you can embed on your website |
| Posting | You share what it makes | One-click posting to Instagram and Facebook Reels and YouTube Shorts |
| Sermons included, as listed | 5, 10 or 25 file uploads a month | Free: 3 a month. Pastor: 5. Team: 10 |
| Monthly price, as listed | $39, $59 or $129 | $0, $30 or $75 |
| Yearly billing, as listed | $421.20 and $637.20 a year for the first two plans | A yearly toggle advertised as saving 33% |
| Team access, as listed | Pitched as giving your whole team access through Subsplash | Pastor: 1 admin. Team: 5 admins |
The checklist
Work through these in order. The first two or three answers usually settle it.
1. Where does the sermon live on Monday morning? If it is already on your YouTube channel, Pastors.ai asks the least of you: it can pick sermons up from YouTube automatically. If it lives in Subsplash, Pulpit AI can work from that media directly. If it is a phone recording, an audio file or a manuscript, Pulpit AI's upload-anything approach is the more natural fit, though Pastors.ai does accept manuscripts.
2. How many sermons do you need each month? Count every message you want processed, including midweek services, guest speakers and a second campus. Pulpit AI lists 5, 10 or 25 uploads. Pastors.ai lists 3 free, then 5 or 10. A church that preaches every Sunday plus a Wednesday study can outgrow Pastors.ai's paid plans faster than Pulpit AI's.
3. Are clips the main thing you are buying? Pulpit AI lists unlimited clips and a caption style editor on every plan. Pastors.ai gives a set number per sermon, with no watermark on paid plans, and does the editing for you. If one volunteer wants to choose and style every reel, Pulpit AI gives them more room. If nobody has time to touch a clip at all, Pastors.ai's done-for-you approach may suit you better.
4. Do you want the tool to post for you? Pastors.ai advertises one-click posting to Reels and Shorts, with captions and hashtags written. Pulpit AI makes the content and leaves the sharing to you. Decide whether the bottleneck is making content or getting it out the door.
5. Do you want a chatbot on your church website? This is Pastors.ai's most distinctive feature. It says the chatbot is trained on your sermons and website, not the open internet, and that it is free to embed. How much it knows depends on the plan: recent sermons and your homepage on Free, a year of sermons and 100 site pages on Pastor, and your full library and site on Team. Pulpit AI's chat is for you and your team, inside the app.
6. How do you feel about AI in sermon preparation? Pulpit AI openly includes a sermon assistant for openers, transitions, metaphors, application and historical references. Pastors.ai's chatbot lists follow-up prompts such as sermon illustration ideas and structure feedback. Neither is presented as writing the whole sermon for you, but both step past Sunday follow-up. If your church wants no AI near sermon prep, check how each one is set up before you sign up.
7. What does the first month really cost? Pastors.ai is the cheaper start. Its Free plan continues every month at 3 sermons with watermarked clips and no credit card, and its Pastor plan is $30 a month. Pulpit AI starts at $39 for 5 uploads, but every plan includes every listed feature and unlimited clips. Compare the plan that fits your answer to question 2, not the cheapest plan on each page.
What Pulpit AI does well
Pulpit AI is the broader workspace. It lists more written formats than Pastors.ai, including blog posts, newsletters and a recap email, plus related passages, illustrations and application. Unlimited clips and caption styling on every plan matter if short-form video is a priority. The Subsplash connection removes a step for churches already on that platform, and the 25-upload top plan fits churches with several services or speakers.
What Pastors.ai does well
Pastors.ai asks the least of a busy pastor. Paste a link, or let it fetch from YouTube, and the work shows up in your inbox. The public chatbot, branded sermon pages and one-click posting are real extras that Pulpit AI's public pages do not list. And its free plan is ongoing rather than a trial, which matters for a very small church that preaches once a week and can live with watermarks.
Price, without the spin
On November 9, 2026, Pulpit AI listed $39, $59 and $129 a month for 5, 10 and 25 uploads. Pastors.ai listed $0, $30 and $75 a month for 3, 5 and 10 sermons.
At 5 sermons a month, Pastors.ai Pastor ($30, 8 clips each) costs $9 less than Pulpit AI Basic ($39, unlimited clips). At 10 sermons, Pastors.ai Team is $75 and Pulpit AI Standard is $59, so Pulpit AI is cheaper there. Pastors.ai lists no plan above 10 sermons; Pulpit AI's top plan covers 25. Which is cheaper depends on how often you preach and how many clips you will actually post.
Where Amenflow fits
If neither shape feels right, Amenflow is a third option. It takes one sermon you have already preached, from audio, video, a podcast feed or a manuscript, and drafts a week of content: a newsletter, social captions, captioned clips in three sizes, a small group guide, a 5-day devotional, a kids' lesson for ages 5 to 10 and Spanish versions of several pieces. It never writes sermons and never posts or sends anything on its own; your team reviews and shares.
Amenflow is not the right pick if you want unlimited clips, a website chatbot or one-click posting. Those are real strengths of the two tools above. On November 9, 2026, Amenflow's pricing page listed 3 sermons free, every feature, no credit card, then $38, $58 or $128 a month for 6, 12 or 30 sermons. We compared each tool with Amenflow directly in Is Pulpit AI worth it? and Pastors.ai vs Amenflow.
How to choose
- Your sermons are on YouTube, and you want inbox delivery, auto-posting or a website chatbot: start with Pastors.ai.
- You want unlimited clips, caption styling, more written formats or a Subsplash connection: start with Pulpit AI.
- You want a full week including a kids' lesson and Spanish, and you would rather review and share it yourself: try Amenflow on 3 sermons free.
- You are still mapping the whole category: see Pulpit AI alternatives and the AI church software buying scorecard.
The most useful test costs nothing. Run last Sunday's sermon through the free options, read every draft, and keep the one your team would actually share.
Pulpit AI and Pastors.ai are trademarks of their owners. Amenflow publishes this page and has no affiliation with Pulpit AI, Subsplash or Pastors.ai. Competitor details were checked November 9, 2026 on their public sites; confirm them before you decide.
FAQ
Is Pastors.ai cheaper than Pulpit AI? At the entry level, yes: $30 a month for 5 sermons against $39 for 5 uploads, and Pastors.ai also has an ongoing free plan. At 10 sermons a month, Pulpit AI Standard ($59) is listed below Pastors.ai Team ($75).
Which one makes more clips? Pulpit AI lists unlimited custom and automatic clips on every plan. Pastors.ai lists 3, 8 or 15 per sermon depending on the plan.
Does either tool post to social media for me? Pastors.ai advertises one-click posting to Instagram and Facebook Reels and YouTube Shorts. Pulpit AI's public pages describe creating content that you then share.
Do I need YouTube to use Pastors.ai? Its main workflow starts from a YouTube link or channel. It also accepts manuscript uploads. For audio-only or podcast sermons, check with them before you commit.
Do these tools write sermons? Pulpit AI includes a sermon assistant for prep ideas, and Pastors.ai's chatbot offers prompts like illustration ideas and structure feedback. Neither is presented as writing the sermon for you. Amenflow does not help write sermons at all.